Today's Fartwa: "intercourse in menses" causes women to go insane

Deoband/thanks to the RoP

Islamic “Science” at its best:

The answer to this question is an actual fatwa from a well-known Islamic authority. It states that “intercourse in menses” causes women to go insane.

Question: 15656

Assalamualaikum,Please advise me as i am in trouble,i got married in feb 2009,i live in dubai,from april i was living with my wife in Dubai,she used to tell me that she is scared sometime,but i ignored and used to tell her that dont fear u have to make a habit and all that stuff as she have to stay alone in the house the whole day wile i am in office as we dont have any relatives here,in these 5 month her MC periods got disturbed and were irregular,for wich we went to a doctor and were using the medicine s,we were told by doctor that the period will come in 8 days after starting the medicine and it was the 7th days she didnot checked but the bleeding was just starting and we had intercourse in that without knowing,after that she got mentally disturbed and eventually i left her to hert home in india it seems a jinn asar as advised by many pf the aamils,but i couldnt tell any of them that we had that mistake,is the reason for jinn of mental ndisorder happened bcoz of that mistake please advise she is still not recoverd,wat to do. Regards,

Answer: 15656

(Fatwa: 1447/1376=B=1430)

It is not satanic effect, rather it is the result of intercourse in menses. It causes madness to women. Get her treated by any expert hakim, she will be cure in-sha-Allah.
Allah (Subhana Wa Ta’ala) Knows Best

Darul Ifta, Darul Uloom Deoband

But wait: there’s more. (you know there’s always more!)

It’s back! Saudi cleric revives controversy over adult-suckling fatwa

Yes, you read that right, and our You Might Want To Read This Sitting Down Department sends its suggestions that… well, you know. Why would something this wacky make a repeat appearance? What kind of weirdo would suggest such a thing? Who, indeed?

(Insert awkward silence here.)

Muhammad, actually, according to this hadith:

‘A’isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Salim, the freed slave of Abu Hadhaifa, lived with him and his family in their house. She (i. e. the daughter of Suhail came to Allah’s Apostle (may peace be upon him) and said: Salim has attained (purbety) [sic] as men attain, and he understands what they understand, and he enters our house freely, I, however, perceive that something (rankles) in the heart of Abu Hudhaifa, whereupon Allah’s Apostle (may peace be upon him) said to her: Suckle him and you would become unlawful for him, and (the rankling) which Abu Hudhaifa feels in his heart will disappear. She returned and said: So I suckled him, and what (was there) in the heart of Abu Hudhaifa disappeared. (Sahih Muslim 3425)

When, per Qur’an 33:21, Muhammad is seen as “a beautiful pattern of conduct” whose every word and action is to be admired and taken seriously, these things have a way of coming back.

“Saudi scholar’s fatwa wades into controversy,” by Habib Toumi for Gulf News, May 22 (thanks to Jihad Watch):

Manama: A Saudi scholar has waded into controversy after he said that women could give their milk to men to establish a degree of maternal relations and get around a strict religious ban on mixing between unrelated men and women.

According to Shaikh Abdul Mohsin Al Abaican, a consultant at Saudi Arabia’s royal court, a man who often entered a house and came in contact with the womenfolk there should be made symbolically related to the women by drinking milk from one of the women.

Under the fatwa, the act would preclude any sexual relations between the man and the donor woman and her relatives.

However, Al Abaican said that the donor woman should not breastfeed the man directly.

Sorry — still creepy.

“The man should take the milk, but not directly from the breast of the woman,” Al Abaican said. “He should drink it and then becomes a relative of the family, a fact that allows him to come in contact with the women without breaking Islam’s rules about mixing,” he said, quoted by Kuwaiti and Saudi media on Saturday.

However, the scholar said that his fatwa did not apply to family drivers, explaining that they were not permanent and could be replaced. “The fatwa is only for those who live in the house or need to get in often,” he said.

Al Abaican’s fatwa was immediately rejected by bloggers as “a decision that is totally unrelated to reality at a time when people are thinking about bold and new space discoveries.”

Many wrote that there was no reason for the fatwa to be issued and that scholars should focus instead on “much more significant issues.”

The edict is also likely to be resisted by religious scholars keen on promoting a more modern view of Islamic values.

Exactly three years ago, on May 22, 2007, an Egyptian scholar was disciplined by Al Azhar University, one of Islam’s most prestigious institutions, after he issued a fatwa calling upon women to breastfeed their male colleagues.

Dr Izzat Attiyah said that his fatwa offered a way around mixing of the sexes in the work place since breast-feeding established a maternal relation even if the beneficiary was not the woman’s biological son or daughter.

However, following Islamic scholars’ fierce denunciation of the fatwa as defamatory to Islam, Izzat retracted it.

21 thoughts on “Today's Fartwa: "intercourse in menses" causes women to go insane”

  1. Last week, women couldn’t work in banks and offices – now there is abugfix which will allow them, if they wear a veil, which we already know isn’t mandatory, except when it is ……/623993/

    Fatwa: Muslim women can work in offices but with veil

    [Muzaffarnagar: Days after a leading Islamic seminary held as un-Islamic women working in offices in proximity with men, another seminary has issued a fatwa that Muslim women can work in offices but with a veil.]

    Some people apparently think that islam is held up to ridicule when these ridiculous fatwas are published, so there needs to be a fatwa against fatwa-publishing. Makes sense, since islam is totally illogical.

    [Open a Fatwa DeskBy: Ahmad | Wednesday , 26 May ’10 15:18:11 PM Instead of doing a few articles on your news site, Can you open a permanent Fatwa Desk. We already know all the stuff to practice in our daily lives. Don’t make it an object of ridicule.]

  2. that is why sex is become everything in western countries the problem is miss underestanding of freedoms .
    you cant ever feel better when you walk in christian countries because you must tolerate to see bilion naked women in the road which you cant cotrol your dick and % 100 you will wet your pant.
    if promotion , freedoms and morality is to strip yourself and to excite concupiscence of people then the animals are the most promoted creaction in the world . lolllll hahahahahahah

  3. “bilion naked women in the road”

    Really, Noori? I don’t recall ever seeing one naked woman in the road, let alone a “bilion”.

    Is there a muslim anywhere that can tell the truth? Just one? Or do they all emulate the false prophet?

  4. let me underestand stupid Mulah !
    how money christian women are living in the world and how money of them are wearing ( Hijab ) and not going out striply .

  5. What about thousand, Noori? Do you believe that muslims should be honest and truthful, or should they lie and exaggerate like you and Mohammed?

  6. I doubt you have the mental horsepower to understand much at all, Noori.


  7. i dont know about muhammad but worshiping three god and obeying from 25 bible makes you too stupid that you dont have any mercy to their family and you are making sex with your own familly . because of this misunderestanding of freeoms .loll

  8. i have advice for you illetirate Mullah !!
    before you guys claim that you are the most moral and ethical people in the world you would block that thousand sextual abuses webbsites to mislead this poor people .

  9. Mullah !
    you are talking about ethics and women right from a country that ‘ homogeneity ” is legal there and you can have sex with your same gender without any legal problams .
    how unusual !!!!!!!!!!!

  10. Noori,

    You seem to be confused about moral laws and civil laws. This is where islam breaks down, it tries to impose moral laws developed by your false prophet, but who defines these laws?

    Western civilization allows people to break moral laws because they will have to answer to God one day (even if they don’t believe in God).
    As far as women are concerned, can’t you keep your ‘old fella’ in your pants, or are you lacking so much self control because islam allows you to do anything you want against women?

    We have freedom (do you know what real freedom is?) but everyone will one day have to face God, the real God not some false moon-god of an ancient Arabic clan.

  11. I think Noori and Anosh are women’s names, unless they are two men masquerading under women’s screen names.

    Instead of intelligently and politely discussing these subjects, they hide behind their keyboards and throw out insults that make no sense.

    And, growing up in a society that does not encourage “critical thinking”, they cannot entertain the definition and understanding between moral codes and laws. Their culture has mixed the two under tribal law.

    Anoosh and Noori, please quote the laws that allow same sex relations without impunity? I bet you can’t. Because there are none.

    And, define, nakedness. You are expecting everyone to adhere to your culture’s ideas of how women appear in public. Islamic women, at home, wear very “naked” clothing. I’ve seen it for sale in the mall and in store windows.

    The doublestandard with Islamic mindsets is that they can just do a sin without feeling guilty and then come away from that action and go and condem someone else on Friday afternoon who is getting their hand or head cut off without consulting their own sin first.

    On this website, we are discussing the oxymoron attitude you’ll have because instead of just changing an injust law, your culture will spend countless hours trying to go around it. Under American law, if a law is inappropriate it is voted on by the people how to be changed. Not just one or two people get to issue “fatwa after fatwa” trying to go around the mountain instead of conquering the mountain by going over it or reshaping it according to what the people want.

    You just like to come on here, hidden behind your keyboard, throwing out misspelled insults. In the real world, you wouldn’t have the courage to show your real face, name or even repeat what you are trying to say here.

    You would be too worried about honor, culture, family, religion, what other’s think, etc……….to ever instigate real, honest intelligent change for your society.

  12. Amazonbaby !! and John !!
    How interesting! Still you can’t differentiate between name and surname. You are too ignorant that never think what you are telling. Noori is my surname and it can be used for male and female. Though I must wait that Anosh clear out your illiteracy but I prefer to say something about.
    Anosh is a Persian name which means “glade “ and its for male . Anosh was one of the famous Persian King during the history ( Anoshirwan Adel ) . Because of his justice people called him “ Adel “ . He was living at the same time that Catholic Churches were too mach busy to show their own justice by killing, slaying and burning the heroes like Galila . Socrates, Bruno and thousand others. no one had the dare to tell the true if you did then you would had a horrible future same like Bruno and others.
    It’s really ridiculous that still you are obeying from such a Confusing religion that never let you to progress until you kicked their ass and put it in the garbage and got your independence and freedom.
    You asked me to have a polite discussion! it really makes me laugh !!!
    You are insulting the holey books of religions you are using thousand shameless words against Islam you are making cartoons of Prophets you are encouraging your people to insult Islam and etc … after all this you hope us to be quite and you run insulting. Funny!
    I ask you to quote just one case that muslims did same like your stupid actions.
    Of course they didn’t, we never used Bible as a toilet papers we never made Jesus cartoon to insult him. Why? Because we love Jesus as mach as you are but not the Jesus that you are talking about (triune – father, son, holey spirit) three confusing Gods.
    But the hero and great prophet who fought until his death to turn the people from ignorance.
    Mr/Ms Amazonbaby I prefer to tell you something about the law and the moral codes because you are too ignorant that never think what are you telling. You are criticizing on yourself by telling this.
    Basically when we prepare to make laws in a civil society then we must attention carefully to some important values which are Customs and cultures, moral or ethics which is based on the society, faith or believes and etc…
    People are very sensitive to each of them so that it seems each ones are important and have close relationship to each others in this case you cant eliminate on of them , if you do then you turn the society into a jungle . Same like yours country.
    If someone injured you then you will refer to court and get your revenge according the civil law and penal code but if someone call you “Black Dogs ‘then what? If someone do not permit you to pray in “White People’s Churches “then what ? If your own son that you growth him up and tolerate thousand of troubles because of him “kick you out’ from your own home and put you in the orphanage then what ? if someone rape your kids and women then what ? If someone use your holey book as a toilet paper in your own country
    then what? It seems that both of them are important to make law in civil society.
    And besides all parliamentary assembly recalls its resolution: to respect religious beliefs but you ethical and polite people doing inverse. You makes rules then breaks it
    The Parliamentary Assembly recalls its Resolution 1510 (2006) on freedom of expression and respect for religious beliefs and reiterates its commitment to the freedom of expression (Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, ETS No. 5, hereafter “the Convention) .
    take note of Resolution 1510 (2006) on freedom of expression and respect for religious beliefs together with this recommendation and forward both texts to the relevant national ministries and authorities.

    « Western civilization allows people to break moral laws because they will have to answer to God one day (even if they don’t believe in God) «

    I don’t understand? You allow people to break moral laws because they answer for their sin to God personally. In one side you are claiming that you are loyal for Jesus and you will follow his ways precisely and inverse after awhile turning backs to him. How funny.
    Let me understand did Jesus tell you that if two lesbians sexing with each others you just watch them out and do nothing? Did he tell you if you see two gays who are sexing you do nothing? Did he tell you that if you see son with mom, dad with son and dad with their daughter are sexing you just do nothing? Did he tell you when someone rape a kid you just see and do nothing? Did he tell you to sex with everyone you want ? And thousand others ?????????
    Fore sure he didn’t !! you believe that he sacrifice himself for their followers sins to forgive them but you stupid followers preparing everything for people to sin and have sex with their own gender and do crimes.

    »Anoosh and Noori, please quote the laws that allow same sex relations without impunity? I bet you can’t. Because there are none.«

    You are telling this while you are living inside lots of gays , shemales, lesbians clubs which you can go their easily and make sex .I am sure you have gone there many times .
    President Hussuin Obama personally declared that ( homogenous ) could share with the army and no one should disturb them in 15 Nov 2009 .
    Homogeneity has been ratified as a article in parliamentary of ( Portugal ) country by supporting of leftist Parties in 8 june 2010 according the( Adyan News ) Report .
    In many state of America “homogeneity “ is legal and people of their doing it without any trouble . Thousand of websites are witness about.
    Same at the Israel and hundred other states.

    Maybe some muslims women do the same stupid action which your women doing everyday in western countries . its nothing to surprise because the society , people and friend are effective there to anyone . its cleared by psychology , that is nothing to say about.
    But the difference is that muslims women will ask you money there as you told but Christian women give you free .

    You are talking about copying that Muslims copy your attitude sending ( fatwa after fatwa) I think you are right . that is why our one God is Changed to three and our one holey book is changed to more than 25 . and I don’t know up to 2040 how money books will we have and how money Gods will be emerged .
    You told me that I hide myself behind the keyboard and writing you but I am not sure that you have the courage to come here after you see my face . believe me .
    Love this site that we could say our expression freely !!

  13. Noori, I do not make any claim to being most moral or ethical; my life is full of immorality and lack of ethics, for I am sinful by nature.

    My only claim, and the only one that God will accept, is to be redeemed by the precious shed blood of Jesus Christ, the Lamb of God who took my sins upon Him on the cross at Calvary.

    This is the crucifixion that allah, the false prophet Mohammed and muslims deny, reject, mock and blaspheme against.

    What will you do, Noori? Time is fast running out for islam and muslims.

  14. Noori, many of the things you have written are the prophesied signs of the end times; precursors of the return of Jesus Christ for the church, the Great Tribulation, concluding with the gathering of the nations against Israel (Armageddon).

    The Law of God is perfect, and requires perfect obedience. One breach, one transgression, is enough to condemn the transgressor to death and hell. The Grace of God is based not on our ability to keep the Law, but on Jesus Christ living a sin free life, and taking the punishments for our sins upon Himself on the cross at Calvary.

    As long as muslims prefer the chaos of “sharia law” in place of the Grace of God through Jesus Christ, they are doomed.

  15. Hey, we know both male and female Muslims are insane in the first place. They marry first cousins. They have sex with whomever they wish. Dogs goats and dare I say it, Piggies and the biggie – non halal western women.

    You gotta laugh at these half wits.

Comments are closed.