Robert Spencer in Melbourne, Australia

Yesterday in Perth

Update: Here in Perth with a wonderful crowd, well informed,  knowledgable people. I guess they must all be reading WoJ & JW.

Security is tight, as always. In  Melbourne, while walking down an inner city street, a “clash of civilizations” could be avoided when Spencer  was recognized by a Muslim bouncer who threatened to call  30 of ‘his brothers’ to work him over.

Not in the mood to fight streetbattles we got out of the area, but you can see once again what Islamic cultural enrichment does.

Visit to Max Brenner, Melbourne

Robert Spencer in Melbourne, Australia, November 26, 2011

by PJG (longtime Jihad Watch commenter)

On a day of relentless spring rain, Melbourne – or a select contingent thereof – welcomed Robert Spencer for his first talk in his first ever visit to Australia, courtesy of the Q Society of Australia. The 250-seat room was full to capacity, booked out well in advance of the day.

For a change I decided to put aside my old habit of taking notes. After all, the event was being filmed, and I would have access to the film. But afterwards, Robert asked me to write about the event for Jihad Watch, so what follows is a brief snatch of snippets.

Vickie Janson, Vice-President of the Q Society and Christian Democratic Society, led off with a sobering disclaimer, mindful as we all are now of local laws restricting free speech, and – with a winning smile – invited anyone with ultra-sensitive feelings or a plot to use those laws against us to kindly leave. She then gave us a run-down on what is happening vis a vis the encroachment of Islamic laws and norms, that is, the steady road to control of us by them, here in Australia in schools, universities, workplaces and elsewhere. As keeping up with Islamic advancement and its enabling and funding by our government is now virtually a full-time job, much of what she informed us in her inimitably cheerful style shocked the audience.

Vickie quoted a Muslim cleric who said that there was no “clash of civilizations, but instead a rise and fall of civilizations.” It is clear that to many Muslims here and abroad their religion constitutes the “rising civilization” and ours the falling (not that they would prefer to stop at ours; Hindu and Buddhist civilizations are in their sights for being given a helping hand to disappear…)

Another member of Q called Warren then gave a talk about what he has seen in recent years in Europe, including the car-burning in France and a memorial (!) devoted to the young Muslim car thieves who were accidentally killed when they hid from pursuing police in an electricity compound and whose deaths were “avenged” by Muslim anti-police rioting. These were stories of immigration-related events our government smugly believes cannot happen in sunny Australia, where it is constantly proclaimed that multiculturalism is an outstanding success story and caution is brushed aside.

When Robert Spencer took the floor, it was clear from the enthusiastic atmosphere that few in the room were new to his views and that his message was seen as acutely urgent. He talked of the responsibility of Western people to learn and respond to the Islamic perspectives which are giving rise to Muslims’ so-frequently misinterpreted words and actions, and expanded on the theme that terrorism and da’wa (the call to Islam) are but two sides of the same coin and directed at the same result, the imposition of Shari’a law. Quoting from Maududi’s commentary in a Koran given to him by the Finsbury Park mosque and using Koran 9:5 as an example, Spencer demonstrated that what Muslim apologists claim to be a misleading absence of “context” proves to be from their own side a misleadingly invalid argument, “context” being at least as alarming as verse and backed up by respected Muslim commentary.

He spoke of many topics which will be familiar to JW readers: the Mafia-like dhimma pact, the absence of the “clash” factor as we in the West politely accede to Muslim demands, the campaign of erosion of our free speech which is central to the Islamic agenda, the existence of self-protective Western laws which are being ignored or under-utilized in the interests of political correctness, and the highly successful phenomenon of contrived Muslim victimhood which has the effect of causing us to rush to make further accommodation for them after every terrorist attack and every expression of grievance.

This last aspect was in reply to one of the many spirited questions asked of him in the latter half of the evening. Many questions reflected the helpless frustration people felt in the face of the plethora of tactics employed by Islamic organizations and individuals and shameful capitulation by our own political parties. Spencer advised not only being persistent in our efforts to inform governments and fellow citizens, but to emulate his colleague Pamela Geller’s creativity, for example her “copycat” bus and taxi advertisements which forced public enquiry into Islamic human rights abuses such as death for apostasy and honour killings.

When pressed as to the vexing question of whether President Obama is a Muslim, Spencer could only surmise that if he were, he would not be doing anything differently; the outcomes of Obama’s policies have been extraordinarily helpful to zealots in the Muslim world – both outside and inside America.

As for Iran, it is important that we understand the Iranian Shi’ite view about the Twelfth Imam and about how Muslim “victimhood” can exist in a most threatening and sinister form on a national level as a tactic of war.

And lastly, about “moderate’ or “secular” Muslims about whom so many nurture great hope, Spencer wasted little time. Of course there are many, many Muslims who pose no threat and are not determined to impose the supremacist aspect over us their religion demands they do, but he did caution, in view of fatally naïve exercises of US soldiers teaching Afghani soldiers, against playing with guns with Muslims.

We may not all be able to dazzle people with erudition and quickness of wit the way Spencer can, but at events such as this one we can develop arguments and tactics based on stated intentions of Muslims which are derived from their texts and their own tactics based on principles within those same texts. Robert Spencer and the Q Society on this night helped and encouraged us to work harder, and to devise means in the vital job of defending the uniquely free and prosperous civilization we have inherited through the blood, sweat and inspiration of others before us and which it is our sacred duty to deliver untarnished to our descendants. They will have their own battles, as we have had ours; let us at least spare them the vice-like grip of Islam.

Oh, and a good time was had by all before and after the talks. So many conversations with so many people; the freedom to speak one’s mind; not once being glared at or called a racist/bigot/Islamophobe…!

9 thoughts on “Robert Spencer in Melbourne, Australia”

  1. Sheik – it was a superb night in Melbourne!
    (no -not the weather).

    Loved it, loved it! Thank you!

    It was great to finally meet you too:)

    Robert was incredible. I am so glad we went.

  2. It was indeed a good night, thoroughly enjoyed Roberts talk. For so long i’ve waited for something like this to happen.

    It was great to see you again Sheik, keep up the great work it’s truly appreciated.

  3. The correct response to a claim that “you are an islamophobe” is “YOU WISH!”

    Since islam commands its followers to ‘install terror in the hearts of the infidels’, confirming that an infidel is ‘pathologically terrified (the meaning of phobia) of islam’, is of great satisfaction to a true muslim.
    This has nothing to do with racism per se, this has to do with muslims telling other muslims that the infidels are being properly subdued by the islamic terror.

    It is a three bladed knife – the muslims are upheld by the thought that we are frightened of them, the government pretends that our [non-muslim] fear makes them [muslims] into victims (?) and the people act like divorced parents trying to buy the love of the children and cure their own feelings of guilt.

    I am not young, however, British Colonialism was practically dead while I was a small child.
    The WWII baddies are mostly dead, or aged and impotent, while the people of my generation – and our grandchildren – were not even born.
    We have no reason for shame and no excuse for fear.

    Islam does not install terror in our hearts, merely loathing. So next time you hear that claim, reply accordingly.

  4. i appuld Robert Spencer! he is fighting the good ifght long after many have give up their ground. he is a true hero to us all!

  5. @ Sheik,

    As a fan of your refressingly irreverant and “takenoprisoners” WoJ, I was hoping to see you at Robert Spencer’s Sydney appearance tonight – well, one must not get too greedy, it’s great to have Robert Spencer here, a true hero of our times.

  6. Great to have a true hero like Spencer in the country. & it looks like the Q society is doing a great job.

    With the usual & predictable response from the religion of ‘peace’.
    As per the previous post; they are not to be feared, only loathed.

    Great news Sheik.

  7. “Muslim bouncer who threatened to call 30 of ‘his brothers’ to work him over.”

    That’s 31 fewer koranimals Down Under if immigration had their house in order.

  8. Hi. Just got home from the 1 December gig. Took my husband along; and a jihadwatching friend from church brought his wife, who very much enjoyed Mr Spencer’s talk.

    Glad the Melbourne gig went well – though the episode with the Muslim recognising Mr Spencer (I suspect many more Muslims know who he is, than ordinary non-Muslim Aussies) sounds a bit scary.

    I observe that Mr Spencer was indeed able to visit Max Brenner’s – and presumably will be taking a ‘I love Max Brenner’ T-shirt home to the USA as a souvenir.

Comments are closed.