Robert Spencer:
Charlie Hebdo’s surrender is not a new development. After jihadis opened fire on our free speech event in Garland, Texas in May 2015, Charlie Hebdo staffers attacked us, not the jihadis. Charlie Hebdo editor-in-chief Gérard Biard rejected any comparison between our event and Charlie Hebdo’s Muhammad cartoons: “The difference between us and these people is that these people are organizing contests, anti-Islamist contests. It’s an obsession … We are not obsessed. We are just obsessed by the news, and by how the world is going on. The difference with Pamela Geller, she is obsessed by Islam. She waits [sic] every morning and thinks, What can I do today to defy these people?”
That was bad enough, but it could be dismissed as the typical Leftist fear of being associated with anything described, however inaccurately, as “right-wing”: indeed, it was absurd to think there was any difference between what they did and what we did. Both of us drew Muhammad to defy violent intimidation; there is no “right-wing” and “left-wing” defiance of violent intimidation, it is the same motion.
But now Charlie Hebdo has not just surrendered; it has switched sides and become part of the problem: “Take Charlie’s recent covers. Against terrorists? No. Against those who called them “racists”? No. It was against Éric Zemmour, the brave French journalist at Le Figaro who has led a public debate about French identity. ‘Islam is incompatible with secularism, incompatible with democracy, and incompatible with republican government,’ Zemmour wrote. Laurent Sourisseau, aka “Riss,” now the publishing director and majority owner of Charlie, was shot during the 2015 attack on the magazine, and lives under police protection. He depicted Zemmour on the cover with an explosive vest, effectively comparing him to a terrorist. Charlie Hebdo also recently satirized Nadine Morano, a critic of Islam, depicting her as a baby with Down Syndrome. Riss also recently published a comic book attacking another easy target of submissive conformists, entitled ‘The Dark Side of Marine Le Pen.’ Le Pen leads France’s National Front party, with a platform fighting for national sovereignty and Europe’s Judeo-Christian identity. In Charlie, the political leader of the French ‘right’ is dressed as Marilyn Monroe.”
In Garland, jihadis tried to murder those of us who were standing for the freedom of speech, but they failed; in Paris, they succeeded. I can understand how that difference can change one’s perspective. Nonetheless, I can only hope, no matter what happens in the future, that on none of the days I have left will I surrender and grovel, and shy bricks at those who are still fighting the fight, as Charlie Hebdo is doing, rather than stand for what is right.
“Islamists Won: Charlie Hebdo Disappears,” by Giulio Meotti, Gatestone Institute, November 30, 2016:
Islamists Won: Charlie Hebdo Disappears
- “The newspaper is no longer the same, Charlie is now under artistic and editorial suffocation.” — Zineb el Rhazoui, French-Tunisian intellectual and journalist, author of Destroying Islamic Fascism.
- “We must continue to portray Muhammad and Charlie; not to do that means there is no more Charlie.” — Patrick Pelloux, another cartoonist who left the magazine.
- “If our colleagues in the public debate do not share part of the risk, then the barbarians have won.” — Elisabeth Badinter, philosopher, who testified in court for the cartoonists in the documentary, “Je suis Charlie.”
- After the Kouachi brothers slaughtered Charlie Hebdo‘s journalists, they ran out into the street and cried: “We have avenged Muhammad. We killed Charlie Hebdo.” Two years later, it appears that they won. They succeeded in silencing the last European magazine still ready to defend freedom of expression from Islamism.
























