Australia: ‘Moderate Muslim’ Spotted

But wait:

He wouldn’t rat on anyone who goes to fight in ‘Allah’s way’- which means jihad…

Because ‘that wouldn’t be nice’ 

Muslim students seek clerics’ jihad advice

Richard Kerbaj The Australian

with thanks to Rosie

AUSTRALIAN Muslim university students eager to become jihadis are regularly seeking advice from Islamic spiritual leaders in the hope of winning religious approval to travel overseas and fight.
Leaders have warned that the obsession among some young Muslims to become holy warriors was also driving them to “shop around” for fatwas – religious rulings – should their initial request be turned down.

Moderate Sydney-based Islamic cleric Khalil Shami said young Muslims, “predominantly university students”, frequently asked his advice on travelling to war-torn countries to fight in the name of Islam.

This comes two years after hardline Islamic university students were involved in the London bombings that killed 52 people and injured 700 others.

It also follows The Australian’s revelations in January that a 25-year-old Somali Australian, Ahmed Ali, died fighting alongside Islamists in his country of birth in December last year.

Sheik Shami said he always warned aspiring Islamists against fighting because he believed Muslim countries were being run by corrupt leaders who were more interested in making money and advancing their political profiles than liberating their people.

“There are some people who would like to go and perform jihad,” he told The Australian in an Arabic and English interview.

“I say don’t go. Because those fighting aren’t truly fighting in the path of God. I’ve been asked numerous times and I’ve advised against going,” added Sheik Shami, an imam at Penshurst Mosque in Sydney’s southwest.

He said young Muslims interested in jihad either called him anonymously to ask his advice or approached him at the mosque.

Sheik Shami, who is also an Australian Federal Police chaplain, said he had not notified authorities about Muslims interested in jihad because he did not want to betray the trust of people making the inquiries.

“If you come to me and tell me about something, it’s not nice for me to go and tell the authorities about you because you trust me and I have to just keep your secret,” he said.

“I know I have enough faith in myself. I’m not going to hurt the person or hurt the authorities.”

The federal Attorney-General’s department last night said clerics were not obligated under common law to pass on national security information.

“A Muslim cleric would have the same obligations as any other member of the community,” a department spokesman said. “The Government would expect that any person in receipt of such information, whatever their religious beliefs, would have a duty to prevent terrorist activity and pass the information on.”

Sheik Shami’s comments follow revelations in The Australian last week that Muslims were refusing to give national security authorities counter-terrorism tip-offs, fearing they might implicate themselves or be labelled traitors by fellow community members.

Sheik Shami said young men often became more enthused about seeking advice on jihad after seeing horrific images of fellow Muslims caught up in conflict.

Islamic Friendship Association of Australia president Keysar Trad admitted hearing young Muslims asking their cleric for advice on going to fight jihad overseas. He said some even went to more than one imam in the hope of getting a green light for joining the battle.

“Some people will shop around, what you might term as fatwa shopping, and I am yet to meet an imam who would say yes, go,” Mr Trad said. “My personal assessment of these kind of people is they want the imam to reassure them that staying here in luxury and comfort is OK, that’s all they’re doing. But then they go (and say), ‘I would’ve gone only if the imam let me’.”

Melbourne cleric Isse Musse said aspiring jihadis do not usually ask for fatwas from their imams to approve their departure for battle. And while the Somalian imam had never been approached by young Muslims wanting to join overseas terror outfits, he said in most cases people would only seek advice about such issues from their clerics.

Read also:

Putting the ‘Islam Shoe’ on the Infidels’ Foot 

3 thoughts on “Australia: ‘Moderate Muslim’ Spotted”

  1. “Sheik Shami, who is also an Australian Federal Police chaplain, said he had not notified authorities about Muslims interested in jihad”

    Attention Mick Keelty: How will you respond?

    (a) Act swiftly and decisively?
    (b) Dismiss it as “a question of governance” and do nothing?
    (c) Warn against reporting “Sheik Shami’s” comments, because “doing so could unnecessarily inflame hatred of Muslims” (as you said with Hilali)?

  2. Tricky one. I can understand his not wanting to reveal things said in confidentiality as this is not unusual. Lawyers, doctors and priests and other clergy have similar arrangements.
    He is only being asked at this stage.

    However if a plan for attack is revealed and lives are endangered it changes things a lot and a moral decision should be made. I wonder if he would do it?

  3. I wonder how long it’ll be before someone aims a deadly fatwa at this moderate?

Comments are closed.