Islamic academic row in Germany heats up: Indoctrination to replace Free Scientific Inquiry?

Muhammad Kalisch: “the task of a university is to conduct independent, open- ended research”– Muslims say “no can do”

After German Muslim organizations lost confidence in the only professor or Islam in Germany, officials decide to set up a second.

* What’s wrong with the above sentence? Everything. It is not about the Muslims ‘who lost confidence in the professor’- it is about Muslims who insist that Islam is hammered into the heads of of students unquestioningly, that indoctrination replaces free scientific enquiry. So if ‘officials’ (who are these ‘officials?’) are already prepared to set up a second professorship to replace the first, what does that tell you?  

Dusseldorf -DPA Expatica- After a revolt by German Muslims, a university is to appoint a new professor to oversee the training of schoolteachers in Islamic religious studies, officials said Tuesday.

* Sheik Yer’mami reported here

* German lawmakers, Turkish group slam anti-Islam rally

* Newslink: Police say Ramadan fire at German mosque was arson

Muslim organizations said last week they had lost confidence in Professor Muhammad Kalisch, the theologian who oversaw a teacher-training program at the University of Muenster in northern Germany.

Kalisch upset the Muslim community by writing that there was no historical evidence that the Prophet Mohammed existed. (Kalisch himself is a Muslim revert/ed)

The state of North-Rhine Westphalia said it would accelerate plans to set up a new chair of Islamic education at the university.

Kalisch would keep his professorship but the newcomer would head the training courses.

Germany is preparing to introduce Islam classes for Muslim children in public schools.

The state higher education ministry in Dusseldorf said the appointments process for the new chair would be completed soon, adding that the new chair had been authorized in 2007 but had not yet been filled.

There would be close consultation with the mosque federations over the appointment, a spokesman said.

The appointment is seen as a face-saving way out of the dispute since German university authorities never sack professors on the grounds of public criticism.

A university spokesman praised the outcome, saying Kalisch’s field was Islamic theology, not teacher training, and he had not been intended to run the program for teachers.

An estimated 3.3 million people of Muslim background live in Germany, 1.8 million of them Turks.



2 thoughts on “Islamic academic row in Germany heats up: Indoctrination to replace Free Scientific Inquiry?”

  1. There is plenty of evidence that Mo existed. There is no evidence Mo was a prophet.

    He did many things (all exceedingly bad) but prophecy or miracles sure wasn’t amongst them.

  2. Dear sir,

    I Want to admitt on M.A ON THE SUBJECT ‘ RELIGIATION”
    Sir I wand to admission in Masters (M.A) Islamic studies postgraduate on year 2009 session. UNIVERSITY ,
    when starts the admission on Masters? scolarsip information

    sir kindly give me Prospectus and Application and information for Admission 2009 by post I shall admit surely so Give me all details kindly.


Comments are closed.