Islam can't be reformed, because Islam is perfect…

Andrew Bolt

Why Muhammad inspires the beheaders

This day have I perfected for you your religion and completed my favor on you and chosen for you Islam as a religion. Qur’an, 5:3


Dr Denis MacEoin is a former lecturer in Arabic and Islamic Studies and a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Gatestone Institute. He, too, calls for a reform of Islam, although I am increasingly pessimistic about that being even possible:

The problem is simpler than any politician or moderate Muslim or Christian outreach foundation journalist has ever been willing to admit: Many Muslims who want to turn young believers away from jihad or hatred of Christians, Jews and other non-believers are trapped. They are trapped because the Qur’an—the six compilations of sacred traditions (the ahadith), which make up holy writ, as well as the biography of Muhammad (the sira)—all condone or command jihad and hatred for non-believers, and they do so abundantly.

Muhammad led his followers into some 27 battles and his successors conquered half the known world. Muhammad himself ordered or supported assassinations of individuals or groups. One well-documented list shows 43 occasions on which such killings took place, usually because someone had insulted the prophet.  A modern Muslim website carries a translation by the American convert Aisha Abdurrahman Bewley of part of a work by the 12th-century jurisprudent Ibn Iyad, entitled, “The proof of the necessity of killing anyone who curses the Prophet or finds fault with him.”

It is hard for a young man, who wants to emulate the only “true role model,” to ignore Muhammad’s regular use of jihad; and even harder to be seen to contradict verses from what he and his community consider to be God’s word, the last divine revelation to mankind.

Here is just one well-known Qur’anic passage (2: 190-191): “Fight in the way of God with those who fight with you… And kill them wherever you find them, and drive them out from whence they drove you out, for persecution is worse than slaughter; do not fight with them at the Sacred Mosque until they fight with you in it, but if they do fight you, then slay them; such is the recompense of the unbelievers.”

Yet for some reason, commentators and politicians still wonder where the fighters of the Islamic State or the would-be assassins of Salman Rushdie or the killer of Theo van Gogh get their inspiration


And indeed, so it is taught in an Islamic school in Canada, of all places:

6 thoughts on “Islam can't be reformed, because Islam is perfect…”

  1. Brin Lilley says Islamic practices are unacceptable. The judge also says so, and gives prison sentences to the Muslims. But to me “unacceptable” means that these Muslims are not acceptable in Canada. They must be repatriated.

  2. Muhammadans must be repatriated.”

    Ensure the following steps are carried out ….
    1. Incarcerate all Western Politician and Political Criminals(Assistors/Enablers of ISLAM and Traitors/Seditionists against The West).
    2. Stop ALL Muhammadan immigration to The West.
    3. Expel ALL Muhammadans -(after Sterilisation)- from The West.
    4. “Expel” ALL unwilling to go Muhammadans.
    5. Bulldoze ALL islam’s “Mostgrotesque” Mosques.
    6. Expel ALL -(survived their incarceration)- “Dhimmis” from The West.
    7. “Expel” ALL unwilling to go -(survived their incarceration)- “Dhimmis”.

    Segregate each and every Muhammadan from Civilised non-Muhammadan Society – for the Muhammadans lifetime !

  3. Daniel. Agreed.

    To make the Jihadis come out of the woodwork, the givernment should turn a blind eye to ISIS propaganda in the UK, Australia etc. I think they are doing it anyway.

    Then take away their passports. This will infuriate the Jihadis, and they and others, will leave without their IDs and passports.

    Now they cant come back as they dont have any valid documentation. And we do not have the onerous task of refusing entry to Jihadis who have passports.

  4. Get Rid Of the Muhammadans.
    111 When Mentioning The Muhammadan (Muslim) word in public and/or in everyday life – listeners tend to get a blank or a far away look suddenly on their faces (one actually/nearly burst into tears) – all so sad.

    Perhaps – This indicates the Starting/Extension of their education process on ISLAM (The Eradication Of) – so it is good.

  5. I know almost everything about islam (unfortunately; although it’s members never cease to amaze and sicken me with creative new atrocities) simply because it has its core (the Qur’an, 2 sahih and 4 less-so ahadith, the Sirat, and the 4 Sunni and 1 Shia maddhab fiqhs of sharia) and that’s it!

    They cannot add to it, nor “reform” any of it; islam cannot and will not ever change, in any way, because it’s the “perfect” word of allah, and the metaphoric so-called “gates of ijtihad” (interpretation) have been closed for centuries!

    Surah Al-Ma’idah 5.3 informs Muslims that Allah has PERFECTED Islam. Can perfection be improved? Can perfection be reformed?? If genocidal conquest is perfect, how can it be eliminated as a sacrament of Islam???

    Surah Al-An’am 6.115 informs us that “none can change his words”. Surah Al-Kahf 18.27 confirms the immutability of Allah’s words: the Qur’an. Surah Yunus 10.64 confirms the obvious. Surah Ar-Rum 30.30 tells us that Islam cannot be changed. Exactly what part of this is not clear to liberals? Islam is the perfected wart of Allah and cannot be reformed. It is immutable.

    Surah Al-Anfal 8.39 commands Muslims to wage war against pagans until resistance ceases and only Allah is worshiped. Surah At-Taubah 9.29 commands Muslims to wage war against people with scriptural religions until they are subjugated and submit to annual demands for extortion. Both commands are without chronological or geographic limits. They are permanent in duration and global in scope.

    Muslims are admonished in Surah At-Taubah -.38-39, that they will suffer a “painful torment” if they do not join the Jihad. Muslims are promised, in Surah At-Taubah 9.111 and Surah As-Saff 10-12 that he will admit them to his celestial bordello if they join the Jihad.

    Jihad is the Muslim’s get out of Hell free card! If he does not play that card, he meets Allah with a defect: hypocrisy. (Sunan Ibn Majah Vol. 4 #2763)

    The minimum Jihad quota is once each year. If Jihad is not performed in a year when it was possible, all with knowledge of the imperative are sinners, liable to eternal damnation. (Reliance of the Traveller O9.1, Hedaya 2.140-141, The Book of Jihad pg. 18)

    Muslims are commanded, in Surah Al-Anfal 8.57, to treat vanquished foes harshly so as to strike terror into those behind them. They are commanded in 8.60 to maximize the power of their army so as to terrify thereby prospective victims.

    Muslims are promised, in Surah At-Taubah 9.120, that acts of terrorism will be rewarded with extra credit towards an upgrade in the celestial bordello.

    Muslims are warned, in Surah Al-Baqarah 2.85, that they cannot select the parts of the Qur’an they like and reject the rest.

    Islam can be easily studied and known in its entirety, by anyone. It will never change!

    So, when Western people won’t educate them *selves* about islam because our culture defers all thinking to those “authorities” we PAY to do our thinking and research for us, while they secretly know full-well that the salesmen in charge will always sell us all out, they ARE CRIMINALLY NEGLIGENT INFANTILE DELINQUENT TRAITORS TO RATIONALITY AND CIVILIZATION!

  6. Islam will only get better at what it is, getting worse. Do serial killers get better? Do child predators get better?

Comments are closed.