Christopher Hitchens
In case you missed it:Â
“U.N. to make ban on criticizing Islam mandatory? Expected proposal would criminalize such comments in U.S.,” from WorldNetDaily,
The Dobbs segment to which this story refers is above. It is a bit careless — the Islamic organization in question is the “Organization of the Islamic Conference,” not the “Organization of Islamic Countries” — but the information about the imminent threat to free speech is generally accurate.
And yes, it could happen here.
Andrew Bolt:
“We’re coming to muzzle you…!”
Christopher Hitchens on the latest move in the United Nations to criminalise free speech – when applied in criticism of certain beliefs:
Islam affirms itself as the last and final revelation of God’s word, the consummation of all the mere glimpses of the truth vouchsafed to all the foregoing faiths… And it is the so-called mainstream Muslims, grouped in the Organisation of the Islamic Conference, who are now demanding through the UN that Islam not only be allowed to make such absolutist claims, but that it be officially shielded from any criticism as a result…
(T)he non-binding UN Resolution 62/154, on “combating defamation of religions”, seeks to extend protection not to humans but to opinions and to ideas, granting only the latter immunity from being “offended”…
For example, paragraph five “expresses its deep concern that Islam is frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism”…
You see how the trick is pulled? In the same weeks this resolution comes up for its annual renewal at the UN, its chief sponsor-government (Pakistan) makes an agreement with the local Taliban forces to close girls’ schools in the Swat Valley region (a mere 150km or so from the capital in Islamabad) and subject the inhabitants to sharia law. And this capitulation comes in direct response to a campaign of horrific violence and intimidation, including public beheadings.
Yet the religion of those who carry out the campaign is not to be mentioned, lest it “associate” that faith with human rights violations or terrorism.
               
THE Muslim religion makes unusually large claims for itself. All religions do this, of course, in that they claim to know and to be able to interpret the wishes of a supreme being.
But Islam affirms itself as the last and final revelation of God’s word, the consummation of all the mere glimpses of the truth vouchsafed to all the foregoing faiths, available by way of the unimprovable, immaculate text of “the recitation”, or Koran.
If there sometimes seems to be something implicitly absolutist or even totalitarian in such claims, it may result not from a fundamentalist reading of the holy book but from the religion itself.
Continue reading Hitchens and the Push to Criminalize Criticism of Islam